Showing posts with label Lenten Devotions 2010. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lenten Devotions 2010. Show all posts

23 February 2010

Lenten Devotions: Weighing In


"10From the same mouth come blessing and cursing. My brothers and sisters, this ought not to be so. 11Does a spring pour forth from the same opening both fresh and brackish water? 12Can a fig tree, my brothers and sisters, yield olives, or a grapevine figs? No more can salt water yield fresh.

13Who is wise and understanding among you? Show by your good life that your works are done with gentleness born of wisdom. 14But if you have bitter envy and selfish ambition in your hearts, do not be boastful and false to the truth. 15Such wisdom does not come down from above, but is earthly, unspiritual, devilish. 16For where there is envy and selfish ambition, there will also be disorder and wickedness of every kind. 17But the wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, willing to yield, full of mercy and good fruits, without a trace of partiality or hypocrisy. 18And a harvest of righteousness is sown in peace for those who make peace." James 3.10-18

At long last, I’m going to weigh in on the Veritas Forum held here at Iowa State last Friday and Saturday. I know, I know – you’ve all been waiting breathlessly. Well, here it is.

Philosopher and theologian Dr. Peter Kreeft of Boston College was the featured speaker on the topic “The Problem of Evil and Suffering” Friday night and “The Difficulty of being a Christian in an Academic Setting” and “Rationality of Belief in God” on Saturday morning. I was really hoping for a thought-provoking, inspiring collection of lectures and conversations that would address some pertinent and timely issues, especially regarding suffering and evil.

Unfortunately, I was ultimately left disappointed by the entire weekend. Dr. Kreeft is a very intelligent man, and he applies his considerable intellect to many important questions. I plan to read some of his works, most notably Christianity for Modern Pagans: Pascal’s Pensees and Making Sense Out of Suffering, the work many were expecting would inform Friday night’s lecture. It may have done precisely that – not having read any of Kreeft’s published works, I can’t comment one way or another. But what I saw and heard was immensely disappointing to me, both as a Christian in general and as a theologian/philosopher in particular.

At the beginning of the night, the student host welcomed the large crowd and said that all were welcome, including “skeptics.” If I had been a skeptic in the room that night, the end of that sentence would have been the last moment I honestly felt welcome in the auditorium. Instead of a lecture dealing with what I’ll call non-consequential suffering, or suffering that has no immediate moral cause or source (for example, the earthquakes in Haiti, which obviously have geological cause but not moral cause), Dr. Kreeft launched into a discussion of human evil and suffering. In essence, the argument was this: God allows human evil because God allows human free will. Humanity always has the option of choosing evil instead of good. Even Hitler, with all the atrocities he spearheaded, is not a cause for disbelief in God – Hitler is, rather, cause for belief in human causality when it comes to evil. In addition, whenever atheism or agnosticism were raised, there was a very clear sense from Dr. Kreeft that he thinks such beliefs are as much an intellectual failing as a spiritual issue. At one point, he made the argument that “if someone told me that 50% of this audience were Martians, at the very least I’d want to find out if it were true, so I could know who the Martians are.” Apparently atheists and agnostics just aren’t very curious people? This was a major strike against the evening as a whole, in my opinion: opening a lecture welcoming divergent viewpoints is well and good, but if a basic level of respect for divergent beliefs isn’t kept, any welcome becomes worthless in a heartbeat.

I’ll be honest: I found the lecture and questions following it to be scattered, pointless and almost banal. Dr. Kreeft is from the branch of the Roman Catholic church dedicated to the intellectual pursuit of the faith, which of course is necessary, but not the whole of the faith. He also holds to a very authoritarian view of faith, from what I can remember and from this quote, which really does sum up the essence of the Friday lecture in my mind:

‘What is God's Answer to Human Suffering? The answer must be someone, not just something. For the problem (suffering) is about someone (God—why does he... why doesn't he ...?) rather than just something. To question God's goodness is not just an intellectual experiment. It is rebellion or tears. It is a little child with tears in its eyes looking up at Daddy and weeping, "Why?" The hurt child needs not so much explanations as reassurances. And that is what we get: the reassurance of the Father in the person of Jesus, "he who has seen me has seen the Father"’[1]

This is all well and good for those moments of suffering that indeed rise from human rebellion. But what about the families torn apart by the earthquake in Haiti? What about the people still trying to rebuild New Orleans? What about the child whose father abuses her? The husband whose wife steals from him? The parent neglected by her children, tossed into a nursing home and left there to rot? These are the people who live in Job’s circumstances, and even though God reminded Job that God, not Job, is in charge, God also acknowledged that Job’s complaint about his undeserved suffering was right and proper. To my remembrance, Dr. Kreeft never once acknowledged that some suffering is unjust and not the result of any action or consequence, when it was precisely that sort of suffering I was hoping he would address and lead us to ponder and consider.

I’m not saying I have any more answers: I am saying that it seems to me we didn’t even get to ask the important questions. Answering the wrong questions well is the height of intellectual folly, a prime example of theology done for its own sake rather than for the sake of proclamation, and I felt like we spent the entire Forum chasing after the wrong questions and answering them with the sort of intellectual Christian snobbery that always seems to rear its head among the most intense Christian apologists. There was nary a moment of promise or good news to be heard; no mercy, gentleness or peaceable wisdom, which was my greatest hope for the weekend. Thus I’m disappointed, and hopeful that when the next Forum comes around, some more important questions are raised, and some more gracious answers are offered.

Grace & peace,

Pastor Scott

22 February 2010

Lenten Devotions: Safe


Jerusalem, Jerusalem, the city that kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to it! How often have I desired to gather your children together as a hen gathers her brood under her wings, and you were not willing!
Luke 13.34

I am willing. Lord Jesus, I am SOOOOOO willing tonight...

Tonight was one of those nights when I realized, yet again, how different things are from, say, 2007 or so. People just look so tired anymore - and I feel tired. Tired of bearing the constant burden of uncertainty and anxiety. Tired of broken trust, disappointment and, to be perfectly frank, unvented anger that I've probably nourished a bit too well. I'm tired of feeling as though all I do is catch up, that I never get my head far enough above the water to do anything more than keep treading water like crazy. I'm tired of finishing things just before they're due - I thought I left all that behind when I graduated from seminary, yet I find myself back in the same patterns all over again.

This is an incredibly opportune time to be the church, but I'm afraid we're missing it. We, like the world around us, bear the burdens of anxiety and fear, and in a time when we could be presenting the world with a different way of being, we find ourselves marching in lockstep with the anxious, reactive, angry mob that just wants someone's head on a platter. We downsize, just like everyone else. We cut budgets, just like everyone else. We bicker and blame, just like everyone else. And we continue to trudge along until the picture brightens, just like everyone else.

This is about more than money. I think we're tired because we've not been sheltered as we could be. Tonight I think of those holy wings coming down around me, and I want that more than anything. I want to feel safe: don't you want the same? Isn't that part of our calling, one to another, to make the church a place where, even in hard times, people are safe, sheltered, secure in who they are and to whom they belong? I think this is also what Jesus wants: for his people to rest securely in Him and in Him alone. Ah, holy Jesus, help me to trust you, now in the hour of uncertainty and anxiety, this time of fatigue and fear. Wrap your loving wings around me, Lord Jesus, and keep me safe.

Grace & peace,
Scott

Thy Holy Wings

"Thy holy wings O savior
spread gently over me,
and let me rest securely
through good and ill in Thee.
Oh be my strength and portion,
my rock and hiding place,
and let my ev’ry moment
be lived within thy grace.

Oh, let me nestle near thee,
within thy downy breast
where I will find sweet comfort
and peace within thy nest.
Oh, close thy wings around me
and keep me safely there,
for I am but a newborn
and need thy tender care.

Oh, wash me in the waters
of Noah's cleansing flood.
Give me a willing spirit,
a heart both clean and good.
Oh, take into thy keeping
thy children great and small,
and while we sweetly slumber,
enfold us one and all. "

- Carolina Sandell Berg, 1832-1903

19 February 2010

Lenten Devotions: Punt

I just returned from a very frustrating lecture on campus. Before I comment publicly, I need to take some time and digest what I remembered and how I’d choose to agree/disagree/blow it all to hell and start over. But my thoughts on tonight’s lecture were to be the LD for this evening. So I’m just going to punt and do today’s Friday Five, not that it’s an inferior pursuit, mind you, but it gives my reeling mind something to grasp with a bit more coherence than I could otherwise offer. Ergo, here we go.

From Sophia:

Each year you give us this joyful season when we prepare to celebrate the Paschal Mystery with mind and heart renewed. You give us a spirit of loving reverence for you, our Creator, and of willing service to our neighbor. As we recall the great events that gave us new life in Christ, you bring the image of your Son to perfection within us.... (First Preface for Lent, Roman Missal)

1. Did you celebrate Mardi Gras/Shrove Tuesday this year? Any memories of memorable celebrations past?

We meant to do a Fat Tuesday celebration at the Lutheran Center, but planning didn’t get done until last minute, and by then, people were already overwhelmed enough considering Ash Wednesday and Lent that we just scrapped the whole thing. So I went home and ate a pizza. That’s right: keepin’ it classy up in HYAH.

2. How about Ash Wednesday, past and/or present?

Every year, without exception, I consider the moment I’m marked with ashes to be the “beginning” of Lent. I can’t imagine not having ashes imposed. One thing I did hear about this year were several folks of various denominations doing ‘public’ impositions, and I’m thinking we might spend a few hours at the Free Speech Zone on the ISU campus offering the imposition of ashes during the day next year. Seems a good way to be distinctively Christian and perhaps do some educating and public witness at the same time. Also, a Christian in the FSZ who isn’t pounding a Bible and yelling about JAYSUS might be a nice change of pace for some folks.

3. Does your denomination or congregation celebrate "this joyful season"? Any special emphases or practices to share?

The old joke is that most Lutherans prefer Lent to Easter because we are much more comfortable in penitence and self-denial. As I wrote the other day, my Lenten experience is formed by the joy my mentor found in the season, and there are indeed many in my denomination who share a love for the journey of Lent, not because we’re big fans of feeling guilty, but because the introspective, penitential nature of the season has a real impact on us spiritually. In the “Invitation to Lent” our liturgy reads, “As disciples of Jesus, we are called to a discipline that contends against evil and resists whatever leads us away from love of God and neighbor. I invite you, therefore, to the discipline of Lent—self-examination and repentance, prayer and fasting, sacrificial giving and works of love—strengthened by the gifts of word and sacrament. Let us continue our journey through these forty days to the great Three Days of Jesus' death and resurrection.” I believe most of us try to live out these disciplines, as do most Christian churches, and this is what makes Lent a special season in the church.

4. Do you have a personal plan of give-ups, take-ons, special ministries, and/or a special focus for your own spiritual growth between now and Easter?

This is the second year I’ve attempted to write a nightly post for Lent. Last year I simply ran out of steam a few weeks in; in retrospect, I may have simply been trying to say too much. Thus tonight’s ‘lighter’ fare. I also give up a few things every year, this year being meat and Sporcle, and I attempt to use the changes that result from that sacrifice for good. So, hopefully giving up meat lessens our grocery bill and my waistline, and wasting less time playing Sporcle gives me more time to sleep, work, play with the kids, etc.

5. What is your dream for the image of Christ coming to perfection in you, the church, the world? How can we support you in prayer?

Humility and grace. I am more and more convinced that as Christendom continues to die (and die it should, for the sake of genuine faith as opposed to institutional idolatry), the church in its panic is asserting ever more loudly its own supposed position of power and dominion. I am by no means ashamed to be a Christian, but I am ashamed by the bleatings of those who will not give up the false dream of America being a “Christian nation.” We are called to be humble servants in this world, not a dominating moral police, and it seems to me that the first duty of every Christian during Lent is to tend to the sin in our own lives. That, in itself, ought to keep us busy for at least 40 days, don’t you think?

Bonus: Song, prayer, picture, etc. that sums up your feelings about this liturgical springtime.

I was hoping to post “Tree of Life And Awesome Mystery” by composer (and Lutheran, though he works for GIA, a Roman Catholic publisher) Marty Haugen, but couldn’t find a video on YouTube. But “Shepherd Me, O God” is another that fits well with the season, so here goes:

18 February 2010

Lenten Devotions: Who ARE These People?


Psalm 17

1Hear a just cause, O LORD; give heed | to my cry;

listen to my prayer, which does not come from | lying lips.

2Let my vindication come forth | from your presence;

let your eyes be | fixed on justice.

3Examine my heart, visit | me by night,

melt me down; you will find no impuri- | ty in me.

4I have not regarded what | others do;

at the word of your lips I have avoided the ways | of the violent.

5My footsteps hold fast to your | well-worn path;

and my feet | do not slip.

6I call upon you, O God, for you will | answer me;

incline your ear to me and | hear my words.

7Show me your marvelous | lovingkindness,

O Savior of those who take refuge at your right hand from those who | rise up against them.

8Keep me as the apple | of your eye;

hide me under the shadow | of your wings,

9from the wicked | who assault me,

from my deadly enemies | who surround me.

10They have closed their | callous hearts,

and their mouth | speaks proud things.

11They track me down; now | they surround me,

watching how they may cast me | to the ground,

12like a lion, greedy | for its prey,

and like a young lion lurking in | secret places.

13Arise, O LORD; confront them and | bring them down;

deliver me from the wicked | by your sword;

14deliver me by your hand from those whose portion in life is | in this world;

whose bellies you fill with your treasure, whose children have plenty, who leave wealth to their | little ones.

15But at my vindication I shall | see your face;

when I awake, I shall be satisfied, behold- | ing your likeness.

I wonder sometimes if I will ever stop being surprised by the Bible. Offhand I’d guess the answer will be, “Not a chance.”

I’m flabbergasted by verses 13 and 14. In a kerfuffle. Bamboozled. Essentially, the psalmist prays, “Deliver me from the people you’ve blessed and who are trying to kill me.” There’s either a maturity here that outstrips every single psalmist or an accusation akin to Job’s case against God. Either way, it’s obvious this is a psalmist in a real pickle, and this psalmist is placing some of the blame on God’s largesse.

Such is the contradictory insanity of life, I think. God provides daily bread for the wicked and the righteous alike. Dick Cheney, Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh and Pat Robertson all have enough to eat tonight. And, to play fair, so do Nancy Pelosi, Al Franken, Keith Olberman, Hillary Clinton and Jim Wallis. Pick your political poison: God has blessed them with enough this night. It’s enough to make the righteous weep in despair, if you can find them.

We have had such a year in our family. Some unbloggable things have happened over the last four months to people I love, things that continue to infuriate me whenever I think on them. And in the wider world, things sometimes haven’t been much better. Were it not for the occasional glimpse of God at work among the students I serve, things would be much, much harder than they are at present. As it is, most days are okay, some are torture, and some are sublime. In other words, it’s life.

Ah, Jesus. I don’t understand you sometimes. I look at some of the idiots who label themselves with your name and just want to pull out what little hair I have left in frustration. Why you fill the bellies of these people is beyond me. But the more I think about it, the more I realize that they probably feel the same way about me. Because they read the same Bible I read. Sure, they don’t read it the same way I do, but the words are there, and if we look really close across the chasm that divides us, we’ll find the same Scriptures in each others’ hands.

I have a hard time believing you answered this psalmist’s prayers as he asked. As a matter of fact, I have a pretty strong feeling this psalmist never got the answer for which he was praying. Because I’ve been spinning around on this earth for 35 years and I know I’m perplexed on a daily basis by some of the dumb things we do to each other. Why you bother with any of us is miracle enough for me most days, and to believe that someday I’ll awake and see your face, well, like the psalmist, I think it’ll be satisfaction enough. I’m pretty sure I’ll be questioning your choice of companions even in heaven, but the good news is, they’ll be saying the same thing about me, and best of all, our children will want for nothing.

Grace & peace,

Scott

17 February 2010

Lenten Devotions: Larry "The L stands for 'Lent'" Meyer*


‘“Why do we fast, but you do not see? Why humble ourselves, but you do not notice?" Look, you serve your own interest on your fast day, and oppress all your workers. Look, you fast only to quarrel and to fight and to strike with a wicked fist. Such fasting as you do today will not make your voice heard on high.’ Isaiah 58.3-4

I can still hear his voice echoing across the lounge at the Student Center in Lincoln. “JOHNSON, WHAT ARE YOU GIVING UP FOR LENT?” Every. Freaking. Year.

Larry Meyer loved Lent like nobody’s business. Students at Lutheran Student Center in Lincoln put out a Lenten devotional every year, and I’m not sure if Larry started it or not, but he certainly made sure it continued under his watch. Every year he’d give up smoking his pipe at the Center (and didn’t we notice, we who knew him, that his trips away from the Center picked up a bit during those 40 days?). And we would do Holy Week impressively, too – from the Passover Seder (which came complete with warnings about the requisite 4 glasses of wine in the feast and how this was NOT the Lutheran Center drunk) to Good Friday sunrise service to Easter Sunday, even though many of us were homeward bound that weekend. You wouldn’t think a man as relentlessly positive would enjoy such a penitential season, but he did – that’s just who he was.

So, every Ash Wednesday I think of Larry these days. I believe I called him the first few Ash Wednesdays I served as an ordained minister, before the cancer got so bad that I didn’t feel comfortable imposing on him and his family. Now that Larry’s gone, I think of him as I make my own Lenten discipline plans. I think of the year I finally told him it was none of his damn business what I was giving up, that he needed to read Matthew 6 again, and the way he smiled so wide when I said it. Like I’d gotten something right and he was proud, you know, and even though Larry was friendly, praise from Larry didn’t come cheap. You had to look for it sometimes.

So, Larry, as you rest in the arms of Jesus, know that I’m still doing Lenten disciplines, and they’re still none of your damn business – it’s between me and my Lord. But you knew that all along, didn’t you? You knew it was never about who could give up the most. You knew it was always about what you’d learn about yourself along the way, and you knew it was about focusing on God more than anything else. Now you get to focus on God all the time, and I’m a tiny bit jealous, even if I’m in no hurry to join you. Until the day we get to do it together, I’ll just have to think of you as I begin the journey of Lent, and smile.

But I will tell you this, Larry: I’m not giving up Canadian bacon & Sauerkraut pizza.** You taught me better than that.

Grace & peace,

Scott

*It is actually his middle name, "Lee," but the pun was just too good to pass up.

**Hm. In retrospect, I guess this means I'm not giving up meat for Lent this year. Or am I?Decisions, decisions...